Samsung Electronics Co Ltd (SSNLF) Q3 2023 Earnings Conference Call Transcript

Samsung Electronics Co Ltd (OTCPK:SSNLF) Q2 2023 Earnings Conference Call October 30, 2023 9:00 PM ET

Company Participants

Ben Suh – SVP, IR

Jaejune Kim – EVP, Memory

Hyeokman Kwon – VP, System LSI

Gibong Jeong – EVP, Foundry

Casey Choi – VP, Samsung Display

Daniel Araujo – VP, Mobile eXperience

Kyungle Rho – Sales & Marketing, Visual Display

Conference Call Participants

Peter Lee – Citigroup

Dongwon Kim – KB Securities

Sung Kyu Kim – Daiwa Securities

Operator

Ben Suh

Welcome, everyone. This is Ben Suh, Head of Investor Relations. Thank you for joining Samsung Electronics’ Third Quarter 2023 Earnings Call. For additional details regarding our quarterly results, please refer to our earnings presentation, which is available on our IR website at www.samsung.com/global/ir. Joining me today on the call are EVP, Jaejune Kim, representing Memory, VP Hyeokman Kwon for System LSI, EVP, Gibong Jeong for Foundry, EVP Casey Choi for Samsung Display, which I will refer to as Display during today’s call. VP, Daniel Araujo for Mobile Experience, and VP KL Roh for Visual Display.

I want to remind you that some of the statements we will be making today are forward-looking statements based on the environment as we currently see it. They are subject to certain risks and uncertainties that may cause our actual results to materially differ from those expressed in today’s discussion. I will start with our results for the third quarter of 2023.

Our consolidated revenue increased 12.3% sequentially to KRW 67.4 trillion, with the release of new smartphone models and increased sales of premium display products being the main contributors. Consolidated gross profit increased 13.2%, up KRW 2.4 trillion quarter-on-quarter to KRW 2.8 trillion, led by improved product mixes from both MX and display. Gross margin also increased slightly to 30.8% from 30.6% in the previous quarter.

SG&A expenses grew KRW 0.7 trillion quarter-on-quarter to KRW 18.4 trillion, as advertising and promotional spending increased with the release of new smartphone models, while we continued our large-scale commitment to R&D for future growth. However, as a percentage of sales, SG&A expenses decreased by 2.3 percentage points to 27.2%.

Operating profit was KRW 2.4 trillion, up KRW 1.8 trillion sequentially, driven by strong sales of flagship models in MX, increased demand in display, thanks to strong demand for major clients’ new products. And DS division’s narrowed losses compared to the previous quarter.

I will now provide high-level overviews of our performance and outlooks. In representatives of the business units, we’ll provide more details following my presentation. For the DS division, memory reduced its losses quarter-on-quarter mainly due to sales growth of high value-added products and a rise in ASP. For our system semiconductor businesses, results remain subdued with a delayed demand recovery in major applications. However, in foundry, new backlog from design wins reached a new quarterly high. In display, the mobile panel business recorded a significant increase in profit, thanks to the release of new flagship models by its major customers, all the large panel business reduced its losses as it improvements in both yields and cost efficiencies.

The DX division again posted solid quarterly results despite a highly competitive market as it delivered strong sales growth of premium smartphones and TVs. In the Network business, sales decreased in major overseas markets, including North America as mobile carriers scale back their investments. The Digital Appliances business reported similar earnings year-on-year in a period of weaker seasonality. Harman notched a new high for quarterly operating profit led by sales growth in car audio products, amid an overall increase in orders from automotive customers and also consumer audio products such as portable speakers.

Regarding currency effects, average exchange rates of major currencies, such as the U.S. dollar and the euro had just minor fluctuations in the third quarter and as a result, did not have any significant effect on our consolidated operating profit when compared to the previous quarter.

Now I would like to share our business outlook. In the fourth quarter, under prospects of a gradual recovery of global IT demand, the DS division will focus on sales of high value-added products such as HBM and bolstering technology leadership. Display and DX meanwhile, we remain committed to maintaining solid profitability via enhanced strategies focusing on premium markets. For the DS division, we expect demand from PC and mobile to improve as customer inventories have generally reached normal levels. The memory business will actively address the growing demand for new interfaces while expanding the portion of advanced nodes and HBM3 sales should start to expand meaningfully.

In our System Semiconductor businesses, we expect to deliver improved results, thanks to shipment starts for a major mobile customer’s new products, which will also lead to demand growth for foundry. In display, we expect the mobile panel business to maintain its strong performance on the back of continued robust demand for premium OLED smartphone displays. The large panel business will expand its QD OLED sales driven by strong year-end seasonality.

The DS division will strive to maintain solid profitability by reinforcing strategies for flagship smartphones, expanding sales of premium tablets and wearables and capturing strong seasonal demand for high value-added TVs. Networks will seek to obtain additional wins in overseas markets.

In Digital Appliances, will focus on securing profitability while strengthening our product sales mix, centering on premium products. Harman will push for another strong quarter by expanding sales of audio products during year-end seasonality, amid ongoing and favorable trends in automotive product orders. In 2024, all certain macro uncertainties seem likely to persist. We expect to see a recovery in memory market conditions and IT demand. Accordingly, our component businesses will focus on expanding sales of high-performance advanced node products, and continuing to win new orders. DX will strengthen its product competitiveness, focusing on premium segments as it continues to prepare for future growth.

The DS division, expecting that normalized inventory levels to continue as well as the trend of higher density adoption will lead to a recovery in memory demand will strive to expand the sales of advanced node products. We also plan to meet the demand for high-performance, high-bandwidth products by increasing our portion of HPM3 and HPM3 sales by leveraging the highest HPM production capacity in the industry.

For Foundry, we will work to narrow the gap with a lead competitor. By entering mass production of our second-generation 3-nanometer GAA process and by starting operations of the Taylor Fab. System LSI will continue to strengthen the competitiveness of its SoC offerings. In the Advanced Packaging business, which has been garnering keen attention recently, we have received orders from multiple domestic and overseas HPC customers, including orders for our one-stop turnkey service, which encompasses logic, HBM and 2.5D interposer. In 2024, we expect to start mass production and expand the business.

For Display, the Mobile Panel business will actively address rising demand in new application areas and leverage its technological leadership to further strengthen its position in the smartphone market. The large panel business, we will strengthen our position in the premium market and improve profitability by expanding our product lines and improving yields.

The DX division will strengthen its competitiveness with a focus on premium segments by increasing smartphone sales centering on flagship models. Continue introducing innovative TV products and leading the market for super large TVs. DX will also thoroughly prepare for growth, by expanding the application of AI technology, providing tailored hyper-connected experiences via smart things and securing technologies in new growth areas such as XR.

Networks will strive to grow revenue by actively seeking new overseas business opportunities while simultaneously expanding existing relationships. We will also reinforce its technology leadership in core 5G chips and vRAN.

Digital appliances will strengthen its leadership in premium segments via simultaneous global launches of home appliances with AI features. Meanwhile, we will continue to advance interconnection experiences between smart things based digital appliances and other devices, while also continuing to improve profitability through increased sales of higher-margin products, such as system air conditioners.

Harman is expected to increase its presence in new areas, including automotive display as it continues to upgrade the in-vehicle experiences and to enhance responsiveness to high-growth product demand, such as home audio. Moreover, it will further differentiate its products and expand sales through synergistic collaborations with Samsung Electronics.

Moving on to capital expenditures. CapEx in the third quarter was KRW 11.4 trillion, of which KRW 10.2 trillion was invested by the DS division and KRW 0.7 trillion by Display. Total CapEx up to the third quarter of this year is KRW 36.7 trillion with KRW 33.4 trillion invested by DS and KRW 1.6 trillion by Display. We expect full year CapEx to be approximately KRW 53.7 trillion with KRW 47.5 trillion allocated to DS and KRW 3.1 trillion to Display. As a reminder, the full year numbers are projections, and the actual figures may differ depending on factors such as future market conditions and the timing of equipment deliveries.

Memory investments are ongoing in Pyeongtaek infrastructure, which include the completion of P3 and progress of P4 framework, all to prepare for mid-to long-term demand. And the investment portion for R&D is likely to increase due to our strong commitment to enhance technology leadership. And just as a reminder, we dynamically adjust our capacity investments in accordance with market conditions. Nonetheless, we remain committed to investing in new technologies such as securing industry-leading HBM production capacity and process upgrades.

For Foundry, investments will center on expanding production capabilities at Pyeongtaek, to address the demand for advanced processes in accordance with our principle of responding swiftly and flexibly to customer demand. Foundry will also expand investments for our Taylor Fab infrastructure to ensure longer-term readiness. As a result, we expect foundry CapEx to increase compared to last year. In Display, investments will primarily focus on preparing for IT OLED products and flexible displays.

Next, I would like to address the third quarter dividend. Today, the Board of Directors approved a quarterly dividend of KRW 361 per share for both common and preferred stocks. Based on the current annual dividend policy, the quarterly payout total for this quarter will be KRW 2.45 trillion and will be paid in mid-November.

Finally, I will share some of our key activities sustainability management. First, our company once again ranked top in Forbes 2023 list of world’s best employers. Our fourth consecutive year at number 1. The compiler list Forbes surveyed over 170,000 employees in over 50 countries working for various multinationals. Evaluation criteria included talent development, working conditions, benefits, diversity and pride in the company’s products and/or services. And we were the only Asian company in the top 20.

Next in September, we received the highest ranking in the Korea Commission for corporate partnerships Win-Win Growth Index for the 12th consecutive year. Such recognition reflects our efforts and achievements in partnerships with our supply chain, which have included support via a fund for partners R&D facility investments, free manufacturing, quality innovation consulting to over 1,800 companies in the past decade. And support for SMEs to build smart factories to enhance their competitiveness.

And finally, Samsung Electronics has further embraced environmentally responsible production by incorporating recycled materials in a combined total of 15 internal and external components of our new foldable phones, Galaxy Z-Flip 5 and Z-Fold 5. The materials include plastics sourced not only from discarded fishing nets and water barrels, which were also featured in the previous models, but also pet bottles and aluminum and waste glass byproducts generated during the manufacturing process. We will continue our efforts to enhance sustainability in all aspects our business.

I will now turn the conference call over to representatives from each business unit to present third quarter performances and outlooks for their respective business segments in more detail. We will start with EVP, Jaejune Kim of the Memory business. Thank you.

Jaejune Kim

Good morning. This is Jaejune Kim from Memory Global Sales and Marketing. In the third quarter, the Memory market somewhat recovered compared to the previous quarter. For PC and mobile, increasing adoption of high-density products in both DRAM and NAND and the completion of customers’ inventory adjustments led to improvements in the demand environment.

For server, demand was relatively sluggish in conventional servers as IT investments by customers who are limited on the macroeconomic uncertainties but demand for generative AI-oriented, high-density high-end products remain strong. In addition, we received a number of purchase inquiries from customers seeking to secure component inventory. And it’s based upon widening awareness that the industry reached a bottom while the industry goes through production costs.

Focusing on profitability improvement in normalizing industry conditions, we continue to expand the sales of advanced node products, such as HBM DDR5, LPDDR5 and UFS 4.0. At the same time, for products with relatively high inventory levels, we strive to reduce inventory level by production adjustment rather than by operative sales expansion. As a result, our big growth came in under guidance both ASP both DRAM and NAND. So some decent increase compared to the previous quarter.

Now let’s move to the outlook for the fourth quarter. Considering the normalization of industry inventory level, we expect the recovery trend in the memory market to accelerate. In PC and mobile applications, amid normalized and finished goods inventory at customers, our component demand is likely to improve, thanks to effect of peak seasonality, including year-end promotion and launches of new smartphones by major mobile customers.

Moreover, we expect to see a positive demand effect coming from the trends of high-density penetration for both speech and mobile devices, which has been accelerating more than forecasted.

In server market, as cloud service providers, CapEx is concentrated on generative AI the associated demand is expected to remain strong. In addition, the expansion trends of purchasing activities is becoming more noticeable because even several storage OEMs and data center customers are getting aware that the memory market reaches the bottom, as customer inventory level will become normalized towards the end of the year.

Considering improved backdrop of market demand recovery and impact of the additional production cut in the industry, we expect growth of the overall market ASP in the fourth quarter to expand compared to the previous quarter, although some disparities in ASP movements among products. Under these circumstances, we plan to operate a business focusing on improving its profitability. To do so, we will enlarge the sales portion of our high profitable automotive products and expand the HBM 3 mass volume business for major customers, in line with its growing demand for generative AI.

Also, we are now actively ramping up our Pyeongtaek line 3 as a part of the infrastructure investment activities that we have continuously carried on in order to secure mid- to long-term competitiveness and to expand the portion of cutting edge. Based on this, we will proactively address the rising demand for new interfaces, such as DDR5, LPDR5X, PCI Gen 5 and UFS 4.0.

Now let’s move on to the outlook for 2024. For PC and mobile applications, set demand should benefit from the arrival of some replacement cycles for products sold during the initial phase of pandemic and trans high-density penetration are expected to keep expanding. For DRAM, in particular, due to the spread of on device AI, the high-end trends in the flagship and high-end segment is expected to continue, and for NAND, the trends towards high-density based on price elasticity is expected to set as a market trend.

Although demand in server application is improving relatively slow compared to the others, we expect overall memory demand to recover gradually, thanks to increasing demand for and normalizing inventory levels at customers. If the server market normalizes, the pace of business recovery may gain further momentum. But various factors that could affect our market need to be continuously monitored. In particular, we will keep eyes on geopolitical issues and IT spending trends which are related to macroeconomic conditions and a bias towards generative AI.

In this situation, in order to operate our business stably despite various uncertainties, we will expand the sales of advanced node products, such as 1B nanometer DDR5 and LPDR5X and the base Gen 5 and UFS 4.0, while focusing on strengthening product competitiveness and improving profitability. In addition, we plan to actively address the growing market demand for generative AI by significantly increasing our HBM3 and HBM3E portion of sales on the back of the industry-leading production capacity. And we strive to strengthen our market leadership by flexibly responding to diversify this demand growth with our differentiated high-density, low-power and high-performance products for on-device AI, which has recently attracted a significant attention.

Thank you.

Hyeokman Kwon

Good morning. This is Hyeokman Kwon from the System LSI business. In the third quarter, premium smart phone demand was solid despite the influences of the economic downturn and inflation. As it is less sensitivity to prices. However, demand for media and low priced smartphones remain sluggish due to lengthen the replacement cycle caused by a drop in consumer purchasing power. As a result, performance improvements were slower than expected due to a delay in recovery in semiconductor demand alongside inventory adjustment.

Mobile SoC has complete development to Axinos2400 which has significantly improved CPU, GPU and NPU performances compared to its predecessor. And is expected to maximize the user experiences, especially in high-end new games through continued raising technology with high benchmark performance.

In addition, mobile DDI achieved its highest quarterly sales thus far this year backed by the launch of new products by major customers. And image sensors have expanded our business all over, 200 megapixel products from wide to teleapplications. In the fourth quarter, we expect the overall mobile market to remain mostly flat, but we believe inventory adjustment by customers are in their final stage and expected demand to start showing a recovery due to base effect. In addition, we expect our performance to improve significantly, thanks to increase the supplier part for our major mobile customers’ new products.

For mobile resourcing, we are in the final development stage into response to next year’s flagship smartphones. Meanwhile, we plan to expand our business portfolio we are targeting global customers for our modem business and to enhance our solutions capabilities on device AI.

Automotive SoC will start to win design awards for UWB and IVI [ph] products. And we expect the image sensors to contribute to our sales by starting best products and supplier of flagship oriented sales. The mobile market is focused to pursue sales growth next year by increasing the premium model portion of sales. We will also seek qualitative growth by increasing our sales portion of flagship products.

In addition, to ensure a solid business structure there is less a lot over to recovery market changes. We are assessing various options to widen our business area beyond the mobile market. Thank you.

Gibong Jeong

Good morning, and good evening, everyone. This is Gibong Jeong from the Foundry business. In the third quarter, sluggish earnings continued primarily due to fab expansion and lower capacity utilization stemming from anticipated volatilities in short-term demand forecast. This recurring trend can be attributed to the impact of ongoing global macroeconomic uncertainties and the continuous inventory adjustments carried out by our customers. This, in turn, reflects the delayed recovery of demand for major applications such as mobile and consumer products on end users.

Nonetheless, in the third quarter, we achieved a remarkable milestone, the largest new design awards per quarter with a focus on high-performance computing, HPC applications. This achievement underscores our growing reputation and capability to meet the demands of customers seeking advanced process technology in the HPC field. We anticipate robust mid-teens annual growth in new backlog from design awards with a strong uptick in GAA products. The rising interest in our advanced process technology reflects the expanding demand for generative AI and energy-efficient computing. This addresses the need for the superior performance energy efficiency and cost effectiveness.

Our GAA process technology is attracting considerable attention in the HPC industry and our long-term capacity planning will be aligned with the evolving demands. Since last year, we have been producing 3-nanometer GAA products in volume. Concurrently, we are dedicated to advancing the second generation of our 3-nanometer GAA technology in line with our strategic road map and progressing well with 2-nanometer GAA technology for mass production in 2025.

In this month, we held the Samsung Foundry Forum SFF and SAF 2023 in Japan and Germany. During these events, we showcased our updated process technology road map for both advanced and mature nodes, presented our design platforms in the ecosystem and share insights into our long-term capacity planning. This comprehensive presentation also included a dedicated session on our automotive and HPC solutions.

Where we introduced our 5-nanometer EM ramp, namely Embedded Magnetic RAM offerings. In addition, we actively promoted the multi-die integration alliance together with our ecosystem partners. We emphasize the importance of collaboration as a key to success in the chiplet and advanced packaging industry.

In the fourth quarter, uncertainties persist regarding the market’s recovery driven by wars and geopolitical risks, a gradual demand rebound and ongoing customer inventory adjustments. Nevertheless, we are observing initial indications of demand gradually stabilizing and improving, spurred by recovering consumer sentiment, easing inflation and major customers introducing new products, particularly in the PC and mobile segments.

To capture the upcoming increases in customer demand, we will prioritize enhancing our GAA technology focusing on the top-tier performance and energy efficiency. We are fully committed to expanding our product portfolio through continuous development of specialized process technologies including 5-nanometer RF and EM RAM, Embedded Magnetic RAM technology.

That concludes my key message from the Foundry business. Thank you.

Casey Choi

Hello. I’m Casey Choi, from the Corporate Strategy team at Samsung Display. I will now brief you on our results for the third quarter of 2023. For the Mobile Display business, market demand increased slightly quarter-on-quarter. Notably, with the polarized trend intensifying between low and amid and high-end markets. We achieved solid results by focusing on premium OLED.

For the Large Display business, amid muted demand, we concentrated on high-end products, such as gaming monitors, and at the same time, we improved our bottom line by building stronger operational fundamentals, enabling in yields and reduce the loss.

Next, I will share our outlook and strategy for the fourth quarter and 2024. For the Mobile Display business, we expect an increase in sales, thanks to seasonal effects in the smartphone and IT markets. But the growth would be limited as lingering inflation and high interest rates weigh on consumer sentiment. Yet we will strive to generate similar results quarter-on-quarter against all out by leveraging our competitiveness in the high-end market. That shows a relatively strong demand and new foldable product offerings.

For the Large Display business, despite concerns over a prolonged tepid demand due to economic downturn, we’ll strive to offset our losses by improving our product mix with a larger share of monitors. In 2024, in spite of persistent and adverse macroeconomic uncertainties will double down on our efforts to continuously secure robust results by utilizing our unrivaled capability, including preemptive investment and technology development and our ability to manage reliable product quality and yield.

Also, our strategic customers are releasing. OLED products in earnest in the foldable smartphone, IT OLED, automotive and gaming segments that we have been committed to for business diversification for several years. We will actively promote the unique selling point of OLED, thereby creating a turning point in the market.

In particular, we will maintain our leadership in Display industry by developing technology that caters to customers’ needs and complete upstream and downstream supply chain in the high-potential AR/VR market. Thank you.

Daniel Araujo

Hi, everyone. This is Daniel Araujo from the Mobile Experience division. I’d like to share our results for 2023, Q3 and the outlook for Q4 and next year. In Q3, global smartphone market demand have rebounded, leading to market growth quarter-on-quarter. MX sales and operating profit both increased quarter-on-quarter, thanks to the successful launch of our new flagship models. New foldables, tablets and wearables all showed strong sales led by a smooth supply and the S23, which we released in the first half of the year, also maintained solid sales momentum.

The portion of flagship sales in our major product lines increased, thus raising ASP and growing overall sales. Together with continuous efforts to enhance resource allocation, we achieved solid double-digit profitability.

Next, let me share the outlook for Q4. Due to seasonality, the smartphone market is expected to grow and the competition to intensify, especially in the premium segment. Competition within the mass market segment is also expected to intensify. And given the geopolitical situation, market uncertainties remain.

As for the MX business, we will continue steady sales of our new foldable products as well as the S23 series with various sales promotions in anticipation of the year-end holiday season. For tablets and wearables, we will expand sales focused on new premium products by actively leveraging seasonality and strengthening marketing campaigns in close collaboration with our partners. As competition in the smartphone market intensifies and economic uncertainties remain, we will make every effort to expand flagship-oriented sales and upselling in order to increase revenue and profits year-on-year.

Next, let me share the outlook for 2024. In 2022 to ’23, contraction of the smartphone market continued due to prolonged economic uncertainties. In 2024, however, market demand is expected to turnaround as consumer sentiment stabilizes in anticipation of a soft landing of the global economy, with the premium segment continuing steady growth. Similarly, the tablet market also contracted in 2022 and ’23 compared to 2021’s high demand related to remote worth and education, but is expected to turn around in 2024, with growth focused on the premium segment as the replacement cycle approaches.

In wearables, the smartwatch market is forecast to grow by double digits given the replacement cycle together with health-related demand in advanced markets and an increasing penetration rate in emerging markets. The TWS market is expected to grow slightly, mainly due to expansion of the mass market segment primarily in emerging markets.

As for the MX business, in line with our customers’ needs, we are striving to refine and enhance the core experience of premium smartphones even further. And as a global leader of the foldables market, widens the gap with our competitors. Through these efforts, we aim to grow annual flagship shipments by double digits and achieve smartphone revenue growth exceeding the market growth. In tablets, we’re focused on boosting sales by strengthening the premium product lineup to meet consumer preferences for large screens and further advancing experiences such as the S-PEN.

For wearables, we will increase their contribution to profits by expanding sales, focusing on newer models and increasing the attach rate to smartphones by providing a stronger connected experience. In particular, we will actively address customer demand related to healthy living by strengthening wellness features of the Galaxy Watch.

While for TWS will focus on establishing a full lineup that can address the growing mass market segment as well as strengthen high-quality sound, active noise cancellation, fit and other aspects of premium Galaxy Buds products. Through these efforts we aim to grow annual revenue and profit in 2024 while also continuing to enhance resource allocation in response to market instability in our effort to secure strong profitability.

Furthermore, we’re trying to create meaningful innovations by applying generative AI technology, beginning with a core functionality that people need the most and use every day. We provide our customers with more creative, convenient and hyper-personalized functionality starting next year. Additionally, in future growth areas like XR, Digital Health and Digital Wallet, we’re strengthening investment and advanced R&D in order to secure core technology and collaborating closely with partners from the initial stages to build an ecosystem so that the MX business continues its growth in the mid-to long term as well. Thank you.

Kyungle Rho

Good morning. I’m Kyungle Roh from the Sales and Marketing team of Visual Display. First, I would like to review the market conditions and our performance in the third quarter of 2023. TV market demand increased quarter-on-quarter mainly due to seasonality, but decreased slightly year-on-year as the consumer sentiment continued to decline amid the influence of various macro factors.

For Samsung, we expanded our leadership in the premium market by focusing on sales of high value-added products such as Neo QLED, OLED, super-big TV. And we improved year-on-year profitability by reducing overall cost, including material cost.

Now let me go over the outlook for the fourth quarter and 2024. In the fourth quarter, we expect demand uncertainty to continue to various risk in the business environment, but demand should remain solid for premium products such as QLED, OLED and super-big TV. That said, we expect competition to intensify as companies respond to peak seasonality. At Samsung, we will continue to strengthen the competitiveness of online and applying channels to capture peak season demand and focus on securing profitability.

By continuing to improve the mix centering on high value-added product lines such as Neo QLED, 98″ super-big TV, Lifestyle screen. Regarding the TV market in 2024 demand is likely to fluctuate depending on the impact of external risk that continue from this year and consumer sentiment is expected to improve slightly from its current weakening trend and ease the decline in the market demand compared to this year.

We will continue to innovate products centering on premium lifestyle screen and the ultrahigh definition ultra-large-sized TV market. Targeting demand linked to several sporting events scheduled to be held in 2024. Moreover, we will provide differentiated screen experience and continue to actively promote not only the basic competitiveness of our TV products such as picture quality and sound quality, but also product features related to earlier that are highly valued by our consumer recently, such as the environment, security and content. Thank you.

Ben Suh

So that sums up the third quarter results presentations. Before we move on to the Q&A session, I would like to share several data points in key business areas.

Comparative figures are on a sequential basis for quarterly data. For DRAM, in the third quarter, our bit growth was approximately 10% and ASP increased by a percentage in the mid-single digits. For the fourth quarter, we expect market bit growth to be around 10% in our bit growth to exceed the market. For NAND, our bit growth declined by a low single-digit percentage, while ASP increased by a low single-digit percentage. For the fourth quarter, we expect market bit growth to be flat and our bit growth to be above the market level.

For display in the third quarter, the small panel portion of revenue was in the high 90% range. And small panel sales volume grew by a percentage in the mid-teens. In MX, approximate sales volumes of smartphones and tablets, were 59 million units and 6 million units, respectively, and smartphone ASP was $295. In the fourth quarter, we expect smartphone shipments and ASP to decrease in the tablet shipments to rise. For TVs in the third quarter, sales volume increased by a percentage in the early part of the 10% range, and we expect it to grow by a percentage in the high teens in the fourth quarter.

Now I will move on to the Q&A session. First, we will start taking questions from the conference call.

Question-and-Answer Session

Operator

The first question will be presented by Peter Lee from Citigroup.

Peter Lee

My first question is on memory HBM question. There has been growing interest in the market regarding HBM. Can you give us some updates on how you’re responding with your HBM3? And also your plans of developing the HBM3E business?

Second question is to Display your third quarter performance was quite noticeable, and you have been maintaining the large gap versus competitors for quite some time. Internally, what does Samsung display considered to be its competitive edge?

Jaejune Kim

To answer your first question about the HBM, there has been a rapid increase in HBM demand, especially with the wider adoption of generative following our HBM2E, we have been actively expanding our HBM3 and HBM3E new product businesses. Regarding next year, in order to maintain the industry’s largest supply capacity for HBM, next year, we’re planning to increase our supply capacity capability for HBM by 2.5 times increase, and also, we have already completed supply talks for next year with our key customers for this volume.

An update on our HBM3 business, already in third quarter, we have mass produced and started supply of both 8 high and 12 high products, and we are planning to increase that scale further throughout the fourth quarter. And so we expect our HBM3 to continuously increase so that by first half of next year, it will account for more than half of our entire HBM volume.

In the case of our next-generation HBM3E, it has been developed with 9.8 giga-bps which is industry’s highest level performance. We’ve already started supply of samples for the 24 gigabyte high product and plan to start mass production of this during first half of next year. The 36 gigabyte 12 high product is scheduled for sample supply during first quarter next year.

Particularly the HBM3E product is based on already proven 1-nano node technology, and therefore, it has advantages in terms of capacity scale and also mass production stability, and we will be able to provide key customers with that additional comfort of stable supply. Also next year, second half, we plan to have a rapid switch over to HPM3E in order to actively capture the growing demand from the AI market.

And so regarding HBM, our plan and strategy is to maintain our leadership in the HPM market through greater product competitiveness such as higher speed and low power and also stable supply.

Kyungle Rho

To answer your second question about display and what we consider to be our strengths that are keeping that gap versus competitors. Recently, during the several years, past several years, there has been some structural challenges or threats such as competitors catching up and also the market becoming more mature. Actually, we have foreseen that’s happening and so far, several years before, we have prepared against these challenges. And I think these efforts are starting, have started to deliver visible results.

I think one of our key competitive advantages is on the technology side. As the leader of the OLED industry, we have accumulated quite a large IP and technology know how, and that has worked as a very effective entry barrier against competitors. Even though competitors have been catching up and the market and products have become more mature, we actually see new technologies and new entry barriers being built up such as whole display and oxide new technology.

In addition to this technology advantage, the fact that we are the largest producer of OLED gives us the advantage of economies of scale as well as the competitive supply chain that we have benefited from. That has contributed to our competitive advantage. Unlike LCD, in the case of OLED, there is a complex complicated layering of different materials. And also various components and equipment are key and critical to competitiveness. I think that has been also an advantage for us.

We do know that the smartphone innovations are leveling off and the replacement cycles on smartphones are becoming longer that has made competition more fears. So we will continue to invest further on R&D and also focus on building a more competitive supply chain so that we can maintain strengthen our competitive advantage, while at the same time, expand to new business areas such as IT, automotive, AR and VR to create a more stable business portfolio.

Operator

Next question will be presented by Suyoung Lee [ph] from Goldman Sachs.

Unidentified Analyst

My first question is a Memory question. I’m wondering whether you’ve also reversed your inventory valuation loss this quarter like some other memory companies. Also in that context, can you give us a bit more detail of the criteria that the company uses either to take or reverse inventory valuation loss?

Second question is once again towards Display. There is a lot of interest in the market towards the OLED IT market. And I think SD Samsung Display is currently the only company that has made the 8G IT OLED investments. Can you give us an update on that investment? And also in that context, what is your overall strategy regarding IT OLED?

Jaejune Kim

To answer your question about the memory valuation, the inventory valuation loss. Despite the increase of ASP during third quarter, we actually took a meaningful size of additional inventory valuation loss in third quarter due to some production cut effect and also our conservative accounting standards.

And you’ve asked about the criteria that we use for this. We take a conservative approach when either taking or reversing our inventory valuation loss. And of course, depending on each company’s accounting standards, the level or size of reversal or loss taking could differ even during a price rebound phase.

Casey Choi

To answer your question about the IT OLED investments. As we mentioned during the presentation, most of the investments for SDC in third quarter were in the investments in the 8.6G. Our investments are on track, and we are gaining steadily both on product development as well as raising the completeness of our technology. The definition of success for this project would be to achieve the same high level of completeness in the large-sized IT OLED products, even though they are produced on large area glass that are around 2 times larger than our existing lines.

We, as you have as mentioned in your question, we have started this investment earlier than other companies. The competitors have not yet been able to follow us on this investment. There could be several reasons why. I think, One is the fact that we have already secured the supply chain is a barrier that’s keeping competitors from following. Also at this point, there are not many companies that have both the technology and the investment capacity. And I think the head start we have made will give us a first mover advantage, not only in terms of technology but also in claiming markets.

Of course, there are still the different views regarding the IT OLED market and the IT consumption has rapidly decreased post pandemic. And so there are some risks when we look into the market itself. However, fundamentally, versus LCD, the OLED display has advantages not only in picture quality, but also the fact that it’s thinner and lighter. And so we think that there is sufficient competitiveness for IT OLED. And also, we know that collaboration with strategic customers are very critical. And so we are closely collaborating with them.

So we are going to continue to work on perfecting our technology and further enhancing our cost competitiveness so that we will see another wave of OLED innovation in other applications such as IT and Automotive.

Operator

The next question will be from Dongwon Kim from KB Securities.

Dongwon Kim

I have only one question about Memory, and that’s about your next year outlook on Memory supply, demand and if possible, ASP?

Jaejune Kim

First, in terms of next year demand, we think that the current recovery that we’re seeing will continue next year, the fact that customers and industry inventory have been normalizing. Also the growth in AI-related demand and also the high-density trend in PC and mobile, all are positive factors assigning for demand recovery next year.

Now regarding the supply side next year, we think that on a selective basis, production cuts would continue within the industry next year. Also considering the fact that there has been an overall reduction in CapEx in the industry since the second half of 2022, there will be a fairly limited up room in terms of production bit growth next year in the industry.

On top of that, considering that even within the limited CapEx, most of the plant’s been focused on HBM related investments, the production bit growth in other advanced node products would actually be lower than the demand growth average. And so we think that in these products, the industry improvement, the recovery could actually happen earlier than other products.

Now regarding ASP because there are so many factors in play, we’re still very cautious. But we think that as the overall industry recovers, the potential for price increase would also further increase. That said, of course, that would depend on each product because the demand and supply situation would differ.

Operator

The next question will be presented by Sung Kyu Kim from Daiwa Securities.

Sung Kyu Kim

My first question is a Memory question. Samsung has been going through quite aggressive production cuts. Can you give us a bit more detail of the size of the production reduction by product and roughly until when you plan to continue to reduce your production?

Second question is for Digital Appliances. Your profitability has continued to worsen, and this does tie in with the fact that overall consumer durable demand has been slowing down, what are your plans to improve the profitability of the business? And also, there has been quite a lot of interest around AI. Does the company have any plans of launching digital appliances that are related with AI or services? And can you share with us your overall strategy?

Jaejune Kim

Now regarding your first question, as we mentioned during the past earnings call, we have continued to downward adjust our production volumes. And especially with its flexible production operation and improving demand, our inventory has, after peaking out in May, has been decreasing for both DRAM and NAND. And looking towards the fourth quarter, considering the improved demand environment and also our continued downward adjustment of production, we think that our inventory levels will decrease at a rapid pace during Q4.

Our basic approach is to achieve normal inventory levels within a short period of time. And in order to do that, we are planning to take additional necessary measures such as selective production adjustments additionally. And also for the time being, we plan to downward adjust the production of NAND larger versus DRAM.

Among various products, especially the advanced node products that are essential for high-performance on-device AI products or generative AI. The demand for these products have been rapidly increasing. But actually, the increase in supply is relatively limited given the fact that during 2022 to 2023, there has been a reduction of CapEx within the industry.

On the other hand, we have maintained our CapEx for the sake of mutual long-term competitiveness. And based on that CapEx, we are we are planning to continue to expand the supply of our cutting the advanced node products without any downward adjustment in production. So this would include products such as the 1A, 1B nano DRAM and the V7, V8, NAND. And by increasing the supply share of these advanced node products, we plan to further strengthen our position within the market.

Ben Suh

To answer your second question about the Digital Appliance profitability, we have been working on various fronts to further improve our profitability, such as increasing the revenue, especially around the premium products. Number two, working through the component inventory that we had built up during COVID, which had been a burden. And number three is to improving the competitiveness of our material costs, for example, by signing competitive contracts with shipping companies and logistics contracts.

We have also been continuously working on streamlining our models, increasing the share of components that are standardized or common used also introducing more manufacturing automation and improving our supply chain. And with these operational efficiency initiatives becoming more visible, we are looking forward to a turnaround next year in 2024.

You’ve also asked about our AI-related plans and strategies. We have several initiatives going on that front as well. For example, we are planning to roll out our AI Energy Mode, to a wider range of our products. This will help respond to the increasing demand for high-efficiency appliances. Also, we are planning to launch the Bespoke with AI care solution globally, in all of our products. That Bespoke with AI care solution actually senses the situation autonomously learn the user’s usage pattern and provides customized functions and features. We’re planning to launch this in all our product groups globally at the same time.

Also on top of that, we want to connect various digital appliances, mobile devices and TV so that in the home the consumer is able to enjoy a very simple, easy, but also healthy and convenient lifestyle by, for example, having the devices connected and operate according to process of shopping groceries, storing, prepping, cooking and also cleaning.

Operator

The next question will be presented by [indiscernible] from Mirae Asset Securities.

Unidentified Analyst

I have one question regarding the mobile device. Can you give your outlook for the foldable market next year? And also whether you’re planning to leverage your success experience on the mobile form factor to other devices such as tablets and PCs?

Daniel Araujo

This is Daniel from MX again. The foldable market in 2024 is forecast to continue on last year’s growth in all regions, well as continue expanding its portion of the premium market. Demand in the super premium segment, which is less affected by economic fluctuations should continue to be strong and we’ll see polarizing demand patterns as the foldable technology becomes more widespread and the mass market segment also sees high growth.

We pioneered the foldable category. And as you know, our affordable phones have been well received by the market. So going forward, we plan for foldables to be a key engine for our flagship growth with their clear differentiation and usability, experience and refined product quality tailored to these form factors.

The Z Fold 5, which was released in the second half of the year, improved on the multitasking and productivity experience enabled by the large screen. And together with the gaming experience, it’s attracting new user inflow, and upgrades by customers who prefer high performance and large screen viewing. The Z Flip 5 with its count design and color selection, the FlexScan selfie, and bigger cover screen to help users express their individuality is expanding its base among the younger generation and female customers in particular.

So we’re strengthening tactile marketing in order to withstand interaction points of foldable experience and enhance product appeal as we also improve sell-out platforms like trade-ins, equipment installment plans and student offers to reduce the purchase burden on our customers and broaden our customer base in the long run.

And besides of the traditional EIP or equipment installment plan, we’re also offering various new payment options like Buy Now Pay Later. And considering the high retention rate of current foldable customers, we in to boost upgrades by providing additional trading incentives for target customers who are more likely to purchase.

And lastly, on the last part of your question, we’re open to the possibility of expanding the foldable category from only smartphones into other product groups like wrap tops and tablets.

Operator

The last question will be presented by Min Suk Sung [ph] from Korea Investment Securities.

Unidentified Analyst

My first question is about the NAND business. The NAND business profitability has declined. What is your plan of responding to this? Second question is we, for the foundry and the packaging side, in addition to the, so with the growth of demand related with generative AI, there is a market view that there will be a shortage of not only advanced node foundry but also advanced packaging capacity. In this context, does the company have any plans of increasing its capacity?

Gibong Jeong

Your first question about our NAND. I think during the recent downturn, it was very much highlighted that in the business, cost competitiveness and also the product competitiveness is very critical. We are also putting a priority on these two aspects, and therefore, accelerating our node migration to V7 and V8, especially the recent VU approval from the U.S. government has resolved quite a lot of uncertainty around the [indiscernible] fab node migration. And so we expect that our migration towards the advanced nodes will actually accelerate going forward.

While we go through that migration, we’re also working very hard on the development of V9 to give us additional cost and also product competitiveness. In VNAND, the core of cost competitiveness comes from being able to stack up a higher level, layers of cells with minimum stacking numbers. And with our unique etching technology, we have been able to implement 160 layers on a single stack, and so with this, we have been able to successfully secure a mass production operational chip V9 at around 300 layer levels with only a double stack process.

And so compared to what the industry offers, we have the advantage in terms of superior mass producibility and shorter manufacturing lead time. We expect to carry this into our V9 offering so that we will be able to further enhance our cost competitiveness and market response.

Also, as the client on device AI grows and the server market continues to adopt PCI E-Gen 6, there will be a greater market demand, we believe, for a high-performance, low-power NAND. And therefore, our V9 will adopt a new technology that would give a 20% improved right performance and also 15% improved power performance versus the previous generation. This is an example of how we continue to provide products that meet market demand.

While investment environment remains challenging due to the unprecedented weak market situation, we will continue to make investments and challenges to secure new future products that will give us the advantage in terms of cost and performance.

To answer your question, with the large increase in demand and interest into generative AI, especially the large language module AI, there has been a shortage of supply of 2 data centers, related with AI. The accelerator module actually consists of 4 large elements. One is the advanced node that’s used for the AI chip itself, then there are the mature nodes that are used for the silicon interposer then there’s the HBM memory and the 2.5G package. And within the supply chain, what seems to be currently the bottleneck is the HBM and the 2.5G package.

And so given the situation, we are focusing on quickly increasing the supply ability around the key bottlenecks at the HPM and the 2.5D packaging. While we continue to monitor the supply situation to plan out further investments and increases if necessary.

Ben Suh

Finally, we will answer questions that were submitted online in advance. We have been accepting questions via our web page in advance of an earnings release as part of our efforts to strengthen communication with individual investors and also enhanced understanding of the company. We received a wide variety of questions for this quarter as well. I believe majority of the questions were sufficiently answered during the Q&A session and we will answer one more question on a topic that garnered a high level of interest from our shareholders but were not addressed during the Q&A.

The question is following. It appears that generative AI is spreading globally and bringing many changes in our daily lives. So anticipation is growing that AI will be integrated into devices like smartphones and tablets. Could you please tell us how Samsung is preparing for developments related with on-device AI? And this question will be answered by VP, Daniel Araujo, representing the Mobile Experience.

Daniel Araujo

So smartphones are poised to be some of the most important access point for AI. So based on our device strength and our global installed base of 1.1 billion, we want to establish a new standard for experiences that mobile devices can provide through hybrid AI, which encompasses both on device and server-based AI solutions. AI technology, which continues to evolve is progressing both on the cloud and on device, especially around generative AI or Gen AI. And recently, on device AI is gaining traction.

How these AI models have the strength of being able to provide a very wide range of services, but there are some difficulties in reflecting the characteristics of edge devices. On device gen AI solutions, on the other hand, can be fine-tuned for product characteristics like input data and device usage patterns and also have scalability to expand our services since they can be linked as needed to cloud-based solutions. So we recognize the possibilities and importance presented by on AI technology. And we continue to work to use it to realize new experiences for our devices.

We expect to apply gen AI technology to the core functionality that our users interact with every day in order to be more creativity and convenience. To their daily lives. And beginning in 2024, we plan to offer meaningful and innovative experiences, optimized for our users, most important functions based on their individual usage patterns and preferences. Thank you.

Ben Suh

I would like to thank everybody who shared their valuable opinions, and we will be sure to refer them in our decision-making process. And with that, completes our conference call for this quarter, and we wish all of you and those close to you to stay strong and in good health. Thank you.